Frustrated
I think my 10-man achievement group is done for the tier, if not done, period. People are starting to lose interest in ToGC 10 … and, really, who can blame them? We’ve downed Anub’arak with 49 attempts remaining at least three times now, and still have yet to achieve a Tribute to Insanity. I rather think it’s become a self-fulfilling prophecy at this point: we expect to wipe in the last ten or fifteen percent, and so we do.
Ten-man attendance has been tapering off for a while now. Up until two weeks ago — even after we started losing momentum — we still managed to at least show up at raid time … but there were inevitably one or two players who would rather hit Wintergrasp first, or get in some last minute arena games, or run the daily heroic on an alt or three before reluctantly agreeing to join the raid.
Then, two weeks ago, our paladin healer made himself conspicuously absent. After waiting around for almost an hour in the hopes that he would eventually log on, Annah and I decided to try two-healing. In spite of some initial trepidation (most of it mine!), it went surprisingly well. The pressure was definitely on, but far from buckling under it, we rose to the occasion. It ended up being one of the most exhilarating experiences I’ve had in WoW to date.
We made it through the first three fights with no deaths at all, only to wipe on heroic Twins due to a premature pull that killed Annah within the first three seconds of the fight. Keaton pulled a Hero Bear maneuver to get off the battle rezz, but by that point we were simply too far behind to recover.
We went on to down the Twins fairly easily on our second attempt, and then wiped a dozen times on heroic Anub’arak before we finally found a healing strategy that worked for us. I should mention that while our group almost always two-heals Anub’arak, it’s with a holy priest and paladin. (I go enhancement for the fight, to buff our melee-heavy DPS team and do an impressive 3K DPS myself. /flex)
I never realized how truly amazing Beacon of Light is on this fight. Lacking it, I struggled to keep both tanks healed in Phase 3 while Annah focused on the raid. We eventually decided to rely on passive healing (Judgment of Light, Leader of the Pack and Healing Stream) to keep the raid alive while we shared responsibility for the tanks and anyone afflicted with Penetrating Cold. Everyone who wasn’t a tank ended the fight with a tiny little sliver of health, but that actually worked for us since it minimized healing on Anub’arak.
At the end of the night, Annah and I resolved to two-heal 10-mans more often. I consider him one of my best friends, for all that we’ve never actually met, and we seem to complement each other well as healers. And even when we fail — which, thankfully, isn’t often! — we still have fun.
Anyway, we know now that we can two-heal ToGC 10 ... but I was still secretly hoping to have a third healer for last night’s run to increase our margin of error on some of the trickier (or RNG prone) fights. I didn’t want to lose Insanity yet again. Unfortunately, only seven of us actually showed up; one was MIA, and two others were on Vent but too preoccupied with Modern Warfare 2 to log into WoW for our scheduled raid.
I was a little frustrated.
Keaton and Annah want to rebuild the group. Ignus thinks we should just wait it out; Icecrown Citadel will drop soon, and I’m sure we’ll all go hardcore again (as much as the ridiculous gating scheme will allow).
Me? I don’t know how I feel. On one hand, I was never proud of how “exclusive” our 10-man group felt, so I feel I should welcome the opportunity to include some new players in the achievement runs. And yet the idea of relearning the instance when we were so. very. close. to mastering it makes me feel very, very tired. (It doesn’t help that the Crusader’s Coliseum is the ugliest raid zone with the flimsiest excuse for a plot in the entire game, either ... >.<)
I think I may be just about done with WoW. It’s been one frustration and disappointment after another for a while now, and I’m not sure the high notes (like two-healing hard-modes with Annah! <3) are enough to make up for it.
If I could just sit back and enjoy things, maybe I’d feel differently … but as things stand, I’m under almost constant pressure to make WoW be everything for everyone. One faction is invested in hard-mode progression; another would rather farm lower content or normal modes on alts until Icecrown Citadel is released. And then there’s the increasingly vocal minority who think that those of us who have Glory of the Ulduar Raider should carry everyone else through Ulduar 10 for their drakes — which I’d actually be open to, if the people clamoring for the opportunity had made any effort at all to learn the content when it was new. But those who feel the most entitled are inevitably those who haven't, and aren't.
I’m sorry, but if you were more interested in farming level 60 raids for profession patterns when the rest of the guild was running 10-mans for emblems and raid gear, then I really don't care if you have a Rusted Proto-drake or not. And if you’re new to the guild, then all I promised you was an opportunity to raid current content; a free 310% mount was never part of my recruitment pitch!
I know my disenchantment is ultimately my fault: if the guild’s goals have fallen somehow out of alignment, or if I feel especially burdened by someone else’s enjoyment of the game (or lack thereof), then I have no one but myself to blame. I'm just tired, and frustrated, and closer than I’ve ever been to simply calling it quits.
Emo guild leader is emo ...
Meh.
November 30th, 2009 - 15:49
I know exactly how you feel. A good chunk of my ten man crew faction transfered to horde. I was seriously considering quiting the game for a little while. But I’ve resolved to rebuild the group better than ever, and I think you should too. We can be Emo Guild Leaders in recovery together!
The Renaissance Man´s last blog ..How to go out with your dignity intact
November 30th, 2009 - 15:55
“If I could just sit back and enjoy things, maybe I’d feel differently … but as things stand, I’m under almost constant pressure to make WoW be everything for everyone.”
That’s an awkward position to be in. Can I suggest that it would be perfectly reasonable to narrow your goals? Don’t make Wow be everything for everyone.
Be aware of your guild’s posted goals. The opening paragraph on Surreality’s website declares a philosophy of “fun and friendship first, progression second”. If that description is still accurate, then yes you can let yourself relax away from progression raiding and you focus on just having fun experiencing the normal mode raids, and most of your guildies will remain happy with the guild.
November 30th, 2009 - 18:08
I agree with the above. If you enjoyed WoW before all this stressful organizing and pleasing everyone, then revert back to what you enjoyed previously!
What nights are you guys running 10 mans? I know I am behind on gear, but I would be willing to help out if it meant you were able to run the instance, rather than not.
On a different note, I miss licking Ignus
November 30th, 2009 - 18:24
It’s not easy, but remind yourself that you play to have fun first and foremost, and believe it. Others’ fun is secondary to your own. If you’re not enjoying what’s going on, switch it up.
As for the 10man, I’d cut the ones who stopped showing up only if I had suitable replacements. That means: good players, nice people, good attitude, have been farming and running things on their own to get good gear.
December 1st, 2009 - 02:27
I can so relate to everything you’ve said here, especially the bit about having to “learn” the encounter all over again with new people. I think this is a crucial thing that people miss. They can be all too quick to complain that “the same people get to go every time”, but they forget the flipside of the coin in that if it wasn’t the same people each time it would take even longer to get anywhere. Plus, there’s normally a good reason why certain people get picked for these groups and others don’t
Anyway yeah, Insanity 10. I’ve been through the same as you the past few weeks. 45-49 attempt kills, always having an attempt or 2 ruined by a stupid mistake. We finally did it this week. It was a close one on Anub (Health goes heart-stoppingly low on phase 3, don’t know how you healers cope when every instinct is screaming at you to heal those nearly-empty bars) but we did it because, for once, no-one screwed up.
Keep at it though
I know from first hand experience how disheartening it is to miss out, and some of it is out of your control anyway, but if everyone just has that one perfect raid, it can be done, with wiggle room too (Or shammy died and self-ressed on Anub).
December 1st, 2009 - 07:16
“…but as things stand, I’m under almost constant pressure to make WoW be everything for everyone.”
After reading and rereading your post, it is this phrase to which I keep returning…
Forreststump´s last blog ..Bohemian Rhapsody… as You’ve Never Seen It
December 1st, 2009 - 11:43
Ugh. As far as the “vocal minority” begging to be carried, I know exactly how that feels. My guild does strictly 10mans but in Naxx we were able to put together two solid groups each week, both usually getting a full clear. When Ulduar first came out we had alot of people from what we considered the “core” group who wanted to keep farming Naxx for obsolete gear and wanted nothing to do with Ulduar. Well…now they yell at us when we go into ToCr and Ony and accuse us of being a clique and getting pissed off that we no longer invite them to the new content. No matter how many times we remind them of how it was THEIR choice to stop raiding with us, it makes no difference to them. Or when we point out that they USED to be a part of the supposed clique, they say “oh it wasnt a clique back then” “why not?” “because we were a part of it.” /fail excuse is fail.
December 2nd, 2009 - 08:12
Somehow I still can’t motivate myself to do 10 mans on a regular basis. I do the 25 man raiding and some few 10 man’s for emblem farming and that’s it.
Last week though I signed up for 10 TotGC for the first time. It’s actually more fun than I thought and challenging enough even with three healers (except for Champions/Anub). We finished with 48 attempts left, which isn’t all too bad.
drug´s last blog ..Introducing: Life in Group 5/Blueberry Totem/25 boxes
December 3rd, 2009 - 07:24
Tell me about it.. We beat anub soon after hardmodes became available and had been stuck on 49 tries for what felt like ages, there was always something, accidental pulls, mistakes, disconnects, WoW crashes, you name it.
We finally got it done this week, although it was a really close call once again (anub went down to 2 rogues evasion tanking.. ^^).
December 7th, 2009 - 01:43
Just saw under your ‘nerd points’ that you got your Tribute to Insanity, wanted to say Grats!
December 7th, 2009 - 17:53
Thanks!